Reviews (41)Loved the choked to death mini cookies!! I’m not a big chocolate person but THESE WERE GOOD ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ These homemade skull 💀 cookies are absolutely AMAZING! Every bite is packed with love, creativity, and pure deliciousness 🍪❤️ The detail and care put into them is incredible, and they taste even better than they look! Perfectly soft, flavorful, and dangerously addictive 😍 You can truly tell these are made with passion and heart. Whether you’re a cookie lover or just want something unique and fun, these are a must-try! Thank you for sharing such awesome treats and spreading smiles one skull cookie at a time 💀✨ Highly recommended and definitely 5 stars from me! — PapaBare Customs Thank you sooooo much! Yes my kids found the cookies..they’re gone 😉 I can’t wait to show it off!!!! These cookies were so delicious and they made my little spooky heart smile. My son absolutely loved his mini cookies and couldn't be happier with the little Bowser toy you added. Thank you so much! Ordered the Mini Skull Peanut Butter Brain Matter Cookies from deathsm8 they were amazing! Friendly seller, super fast shipping & the cookies tasted fantastic. Highly recommend! 🖤 #theystolemysoul excellent cookies... banana nut bread cookies taste just old fashioned banana bread... will take you back to simpler days.. can't get enough of these cookies and the other flavors are dynamite another big time favorite at my house!! from the packageing to the cookies and everything in between this is just an amazing experience Hands down best cookies I ever ate .. there is no one that I have given one to that has not enjoyed or loved them . . these cookies deserve an award and a category all their own .. I am not a sweet eater but these cookies have changed my outlook on sweets and now I am a faithful follower and lover of all these cookies and amazing flavors I have to say, this WhatNot purchase absolutely blew me away. From the moment the package arrived, you could tell there was care put into every detail—but the real star? The cookies. These are hands down some of the most amazing cookies I’ve ever had. Perfect texture, incredible flavor, and that homemade touch you just can’t fake. Every bite felt like something special.
What really stands out, though, is the person behind it all. You can tell this isn’t just a business—it’s something she was genuinely meant to do. There’s a natural passion and authenticity that comes through, not forced, not overdone—just real. She doesn’t try to make it into something bigger than it needs to be, and that’s exactly what makes it so beautiful. It feels personal, thoughtful, and true to who she is.
It’s rare to come across something that hits both quality and heart at the same time, but this absolutely does. Supporting someone who is clearly in their element and creating something this good🫶🏼🫵🏼 So happy to get my cookies. They are delicious! I will be ordering again in the future!! Man these cookies are awesome my wife and I absolutely wrecked the oatmeal raisin cream skulls. They were soft and tasted great a good 5-10 seconds in the microwave. Lovely seller, fast shipping, fun show. this was my 4th order..... raisin the dead, and choked to death by chocolate ( regular )....and the consensus in my home is that ( at the moment anyway cuz we have not had all the flavors yet ) raisin the Dead is the absolute favorite! I will have to say the way that this particular cookie released it so onto the plate was freaking amazing my next order will be here in 2 days can't wait try those! this set of cookies was peanut butter brain matter! they arrived quickly and the packaging is so well thought out it just makes the whole product! and the cookies got eaten in about 5 mins flat! they are really good, and this is definitely a liked flavor in this house. The cookies are absolutely delicious and perfect. Arrived quickly and packaged with deathsm8 charm!! Can't wait to eat the cookies with my daughter!! Thanks again Erin!! amazing soft fresh cookies every time! thank you! big ass cookies that have big ass flavor.. so delicious.. so fresh.. and leave you begging for more I normally don’t do a immersive review on a product but these cookies!!! These Skull cookies made by the Lovely Erin. Upon arrival, I was sniffing the box… Yea I know oooh Cringe but read and dont judge. The purple tissue paper was a nice touch. Love the sticker, wish they were more.
Enough small talk…Here’s my opinion and its my opinion.
Ranking from most favorite to least.
#1 Buried Alive In Chocolate. Takes like brookie and loved that its not as rich/sweet. This is Wifeys last choice but something is wrong with her LOL.
#2 Raisin The Dead, love the balance of this cookie and not as sweet. Wifey #4 choice.
#3 Peanut Brain Matter, rich and very “Naughty” LOL well balance of cookie and PB fill. Wifeys #3 Choice.
#4 Snicker Doodle Seance not cookie I often eat but very delicious and well balance on the flavors. This is Wifes #1.
#5 Macademia Morgue well balance on Nut and cookie flavor but wifes #2 choice.
#6 Bloody Velvet Cheesecake, I feel the filling was needed but enjoyed it Amazing cookies. Amazing person. I will be back again and again for more! 10/10 RED VELVET SKULL🤤❤️
This cookie was EVERYTHING. Super gooey, perfectly moist, and still soft even after traveling through the mail—which says a lot! The flavor was rich and spot on… honestly couldn’t stop at just one.
Would 100% recommend—no hesitation. I already have more on the way because it’s THAT good!! 🍪🔥